Traditional Labor Law for Employers
J Barrow Legal represents private- and public-sector employers in first-contract and successor negotiations, advising leadership from bargaining preparation and economic analysis through negotiation, ratification and contract administration.
A collective bargaining agreement does more than establish wages and benefits. It defines the framework within which management will make decisions about staffing, scheduling, discipline, subcontracting and other operational matters for years to come. Effective negotiation therefore requires more than reaching agreement at the table. It requires an understanding of how each provision will be administered, interpreted and enforced.
Bargaining also carries its own legal exposure. A unilateral change to a mandatory subject of bargaining without satisfying the employer's bargaining obligations, an inadequate response to a relevant information request, or insistence to impasse on a permissive subject can turn negotiations into an unfair labor practice proceeding. Effective preparation addresses both the economics of the deal and the record the employer is building.
We review the current agreement, grievance history, arbitration awards and operational pain points with leadership, then translate the company's priorities into proposals, a costing model and a bargaining calendar.
We serve as chief negotiator or advise the company's bargaining team, depending on the engagement, and keep a disciplined record of proposals, explanations and tentative agreements.
We manage union information requests, address confidentiality concerns and respond to refusal-to-bargain charges before the NLRB or SERB.
We evaluate whether impasse exists, advise on implementation and contingency planning, and prepare leadership for the operational and legal consequences of each option.
We draft management rights, scheduling, subcontracting, discipline and grievance provisions with attention to how an arbitrator will read them, and we train supervisors on the agreement once it is ratified.
Jazmyn Barrow has served as chief negotiator or management counsel in negotiations involving more than 75 collective bargaining agreements for private- and public-sector employers, including first contracts, with bargaining units ranging from five to approximately 2,000 employees. She has negotiated with unions including the UAW, the United Steelworkers, the Teamsters, SEIU, AFSCME, the IAFF, the Fraternal Order of Police and the Ohio Patrolmen's Benevolent Association.
Her practice spans manufacturing, services, the performing arts, public safety and higher education, including labor arbitration and proceedings before the NLRB and SERB. As a former Ohio Assistant Attorney General, she served as counsel to the State Employment Relations Board. She has represented municipalities, institutions of higher education and other public employers in labor matters involving police, fire, faculty and staff bargaining units, including negotiations, mediation, fact-finding, conciliation and SERB proceedings. That breadth informs her approach to bargaining, with attention not only to the agreement reached but also to the operational obligations the employer will administer long after negotiations conclude.
The duty to bargain is a duty to engage, not a duty to agree. For most private-sector employers, the governing framework is the National Labor Relations Act. Under Sections 8(a)(5) and 8(d), an employer must meet at reasonable times and confer in good faith over wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment. The statute does not compel either party to agree to a proposal or make a concession. Good faith is judged from the totality of conduct, so bargaining notes, the timing of proposals and the explanations given at the table often become evidence.
Mandatory and permissive subjects are treated differently. Mandatory subjects, such as wages, hours, benefits, discipline and many work rules, must be bargained on request. Permissive subjects may be discussed, but neither side may insist on them to the point of impasse. Before the employer changes a mandatory term of employment, it generally must give the union notice and an opportunity to bargain. Some business decisions, such as a decision to close part of an operation, may fall outside the duty to bargain while their effects on employees remain bargainable.
Information requests are part of the bargaining obligation. A union is generally entitled to information relevant to its role as bargaining representative, and information about unit employees' wages and terms is presumptively relevant. An employer that claims it cannot afford a proposal may be required to substantiate that claim. Timely, organized responses, with confidentiality concerns raised and accommodated in good faith, reduce the risk of a refusal-to-bargain charge.
Impasse and expiration carry specific rules. After a good-faith impasse on the agreement as a whole, an employer may generally implement terms reasonably comprehended within its final offer. Until then, the status quo on mandatory subjects generally continues after a contract expires, with some exceptions for provisions that do not survive expiration. Whether impasse exists is a fact-intensive question, and an employer that declares it prematurely may face a remedial order to restore prior terms. Implementation rights depend on the circumstances, including the course of bargaining and whether the employer has met its information and bargaining obligations.
Ohio public employers bargain under a separate statute. Ohio public employers bargain under R.C. Chapter 4117. All matters affecting wages, hours and terms and conditions of employment are generally subject to bargaining, while R.C. 4117.08(C) preserves management rights except where their exercise affects those terms. Agreements must include a grievance procedure that may end in binding arbitration and may not run more than three years. Disputes follow a statutory sequence of notice, mediation, fact-finding and, for employees who may not strike, final offer conciliation.
No. Federal labor law requires the employer to meet at reasonable times and bargain in good faith, but it does not require either side to agree to a proposal or make a concession. The employer may hold firm on its positions as long as its overall conduct reflects a genuine effort to reach agreement.
Generally not without first giving the union notice and an opportunity to bargain, if the change involves a mandatory subject of bargaining. Unilateral changes before a good-faith impasse are a common source of unfair labor practice charges. Some changes may be permitted by existing contract language or by established past practice, so each proposed change should be reviewed before it is announced.
In the private sector, most existing terms generally continue as the status quo while the parties keep bargaining, although certain provisions, such as a no-strike clause and the obligation to arbitrate post-expiration disputes, generally do not survive. Ohio public employers follow the notice, mediation, fact-finding and conciliation sequence in R.C. 4117.14, which also limits strikes while those procedures are pending.
It varies widely with the size of the unit, the issues and the relationship between the parties, and first contracts frequently take longer than renewals because every term is being written for the first time. Careful preparation, a realistic calendar and clear authority for the company's team shorten the process more reliably than pressure at the table.
It depends on the decision. Some decisions turn on the scope and direction of the business and may not require bargaining over the decision itself, but the employer generally must bargain over the effects on employees, such as severance, recall rights and benefits. Subcontracting of unit work is often a mandatory subject. The contract's management rights and subcontracting language also matters, so the analysis should come before the decision is announced.
Current as of November 2026.
Share a few details about your situation, and we’ll follow up to discuss fit, timing, and next steps.